Sued by a debt buyer in New York: what to do

Checked against official sources: Oct 25, 2026

In New York:

File your answer
20 days after the summons is handed to you personally.
Time limit for suing on the debt
3 years for consumer credit debts (like credit cards and personal loans) when you are the borrower.
Do this now
Check that the case is real: look it up on the court's website or call the clerk at a number from the court's official site, not from the papers.

Make this letter for New York →

General legal information, not legal advice. RobinClaim is not a law firm.

Build your plan

Choose your state and answer 3 quick questions. The plan below changes as you answer: steps that don't fit your answers are hidden, and your state's deadlines appear. Your answers stay in the page address.

Your plan for New York

Do now

  1. Find your state's deadline to answer, and mark it on a calendar.

    File your answer

    New York: 20 days after the summons is handed to you personally.

    Why: If you don't answer on time, the court can enter a default judgment against you.

  2. Check that the case is real: look it up on the court's website or call the clerk at a number from the court's official site, not from the papers.

    Why: Fake lawsuit threats are a common scam; a real case is on file with the court.

  3. Read the complaint for the original creditor, the last digits of the account, the date the debt was sold and the amount, and compare them with your own records.

    Why: These details show whether the debt is yours, whether the amount is right and how the plaintiff says it got the account.

  4. If the deadline has passed or a judgment was entered, call the clerk today and see the default judgment plan.

    Why: There is a short time limit to ask the court to set aside a default judgment.

  5. If you don't recognize the account, get your free credit reports at AnnualCreditReport.com, and if the account isn't yours, report identity theft at IdentityTheft.gov.

    Why: An identity theft report helps you show the court and the credit bureaus that the debt isn't yours.

This week

  1. File a written answer by the deadline. Deny what you can't confirm and list every defense that fits: not my debt, wrong amount, already paid, the plaintiff can't prove it owns the debt, or the time limit to sue has passed.

    Why: Defenses you don't raise can be lost. Answering makes the plaintiff prove its claim.

  2. Ask the plaintiff's lawyer in writing for the documents: the original contract or account terms, the statements, and the bill of sale or assignment showing the account was sold to the plaintiff.

    Why: A debt buyer has to prove it owns your account and how much is owed. Many states set extra proof rules for debt buyers (below).

  3. Compare the date of your last payment with your state's time limit to sue.

    New York: 3 years for consumer credit debts (like credit cards and personal loans) when you are the borrower.

    Why: A debt collector must not sue on a time-barred debt, but the court considers the time limit only if you raise it.

  4. If the debt isn't yours, say so in your answer and keep a copy of your identity theft report to show the court.

    Why: The plaintiff must prove the account belongs to you.

  5. If you can't afford the filing fee for the answer, ask the clerk for a fee waiver form.

    Why: Courts can waive fees for people with low income.

If it's not resolved

  1. Go to every hearing and bring your documents. If the plaintiff hasn't shown proof that it owns the debt, you can point that out to the judge.

    Why: When you respond, the plaintiff has to prove to the court that the debt is valid.

  2. If you owe the debt, you can try to settle; see the settlement plan. Get any agreement in writing before you pay.

    Why: A written agreement protects you if the debt buyer later says you didn't pay.

  3. If the debt buyer sued on a debt too old to sue on, or in a court far from where you live or signed the contract, you can complain to the CFPB and your state attorney general and ask a consumer lawyer about the federal debt collection law.

    Why: A debt collector must sue where you signed the contract or where you live, and must not sue on a time-barred debt. You can sue a collector that broke this law within 1 year.

Deadlines

File your answer

General rule: see state; the summons gives the date

In New York:

20 days after the summons is handed to you personally. If it was served another way (for example, left with someone at your home and mailed, or attached to your door and mailed), 30 days. In NYC Civil Court, the 30 days run from when the proof of service is filed with the clerk. The summons states the deadline.

Law: CPLR 320(a); N.Y. City Civ. Ct. Act § 402; § 1911 · checked Oct 2026 · Official source · From Debt Suit Map: New York

Time limit for suing on the debt

General rule: see state

In New York:

3 years for consumer credit debts (like credit cards and personal loans) when you are the borrower. Once the 3 years have run out, a payment or promise to pay does not restart the clock. Other contracts have 6 years.

Law: N.Y. C.P.L.R. 214-i; 213 · checked Oct 2026 · Official source

What a debt buyer must show in court

General rule: see state; not every state has special rules for debt buyers

In New York:

Under the Consumer Credit Fairness Act. In a consumer credit case, the complaint must attach the contract (or, for a revolving account like a credit card, the charge-off statement) and state the original creditor, the last 4 digits of the account, the date and amount of your last payment, an itemization of the amount (for credit cards: balance at charge-off, interest, fees and payments since charge-off), the last statement balance, and whether the plaintiff is the original creditor. A debt buyer must also state when it bought the debt, every previous owner and transfer date, and the amount due at each sale (CPLR 3016(j)). To get a default judgment, a debt buyer must file an affidavit from the original creditor about the debt, the default, the sale and the amount, plus affidavits for each later sale, and an affidavit that the time limit has not run (CPLR 3215(f), (j)).

checked Oct 2026 · From Debt Suit Map: New York

Key facts for New York

Debt Suit Map

Time to answer a debt lawsuit
as few as 20 days
Shortest time to ask to cancel a default judgment
1 year
Official answer form
No official form found
How long a judgment lasts
20 years

Debt Suit Map: New York · checked Oct 2026

Debt Collector Map

Time limit to sue on a debt
3 years
Wage garnishment limit
Up to 10%
State license for collectors
No statewide license

Debt Collector Map: New York · checked Oct 2026

Documents to gather

  • Summons and complaint (all pages)
  • Any letters from the debt buyer or collectors, including the validation notice
  • Old statements from the original creditor, if you have them
  • Your payment records and receipts
  • Your credit reports
  • An identity theft report, if the debt isn't yours
  • A copy of your filed answer, with the court's stamp

Where to go

Costs

Filing an answer may require a fee in some courts; ask for a fee waiver if you can't pay. If you lose, the judgment can include court costs, interest and attorney's fees if your contract or state law allows them.

Talk to a lawyer if

  • You don't recognize the debt or think it's identity theft
  • The debt may be too old to sue on
  • The deadline has passed or a default judgment was entered
  • The case is in regular civil court, not small claims
  • Your wages or bank account are already being taken

Free help

Free civil legal aid for people with low income: find your local program through the Legal Services Corporation (lsc.gov/about-lsc/what-legal-aid/get-legal-help) or LawHelp.org (lawhelp.org). Many legal aid offices handle debt collection lawsuits, default judgments, garnishment and bankruptcy. Servicemembers can use their base legal (JAG) office. Some courts have free volunteer-lawyer programs or self-help centers for debt cases; ask the clerk.

Guides for your state

Guides for every state

Questions

File your answer in New York: what is the rule?

20 days after the summons is handed to you personally. If it was served another way (for example, left with someone at your home and mailed, or attached to your door and mailed), 30 days. In NYC Civil Court, the 30 days run from when the proof of service is filed with the clerk. The summons states the deadline. (CPLR 320(a); N.Y. City Civ. Ct. Act § 402; § 1911)

What is the time limit for suing on the debt in New York?

3 years for consumer credit debts (like credit cards and personal loans) when you are the borrower. Once the 3 years have run out, a payment or promise to pay does not restart the clock. Other contracts have 6 years. (N.Y. C.P.L.R. 214-i; 213)

What a debt buyer must show in court in New York: what is the rule?

Under the Consumer Credit Fairness Act. In a consumer credit case, the complaint must attach the contract (or, for a revolving account like a credit card, the charge-off statement) and state the original creditor, the last 4 digits of the account, the date and amount of your last payment, an itemization of the amount (for credit cards: balance at charge-off, interest, fees and payments since charge-off), the last statement balance, and whether the plaintiff is the original creditor. A debt buyer must also state when it bought the debt, every previous owner and transfer date, and the amount due at each sale (CPLR 3016(j)). To get a default judgment, a debt buyer must file an affidavit from the original creditor about the debt, the default, the sale and the amount, plus affidavits for each later sale, and an affidavit that the time limit has not run (CPLR 3215(f), (j)).

When should I talk to a lawyer?

You don't recognize the debt or think it's identity theft; The debt may be too old to sue on; The deadline has passed or a default judgment was entered; The case is in regular civil court, not small claims; Your wages or bank account are already being taken.

How much does it cost?

Filing an answer may require a fee in some courts; ask for a fee waiver if you can't pay. If you lose, the judgment can include court costs, interest and attorney's fees if your contract or state law allows them.

Plans by state

Open the plan with one state's rules filled in:

Sources

Plan checked Oct 2026. Independently fact-checked 2026-10-25.

This plan is general legal information, not legal advice. RobinClaim is not a law firm. Laws and deadlines change and have exceptions: check with the official source or a lawyer or legal aid office about your own case. How we research.